A Hipp chronoscope of about 1890 under a glass dome, the clockwork timer with which the first psychological laboratories measured reaction times to the thousandth of a second
Unit 01 · All masterclasses · 75 min

Psychology as a Science

How a question about the mind becomes an experiment, and how to read the numbers it produces
Image: Daderot, Wikimedia Commons, CC0

Psychology turns questions about the mind into experiments, and every later unit rests on how that is done. This unit teaches the design of an experiment, the description of data with the mean, the standard deviation, and the correlation, the effect size and the significance test, the ethics of research on people, and what happened in 2015 when 100 published experiments were repeated.

Preview: the beginning of the unit

1 Introduction

Of all the objects in the known universe, one has started to study itself. A brain of about 86 billion nerve cells, kept at body temperature inside a skull, asks what it is doing when it sees, remembers, decides, and loves, and it tries to answer with the only instrument available, which is another brain of the same kind. Psychology is the science that came out of this strange situation. Its subject matter is the one thing every reader has first-hand access to and almost no reader knows well.

Consider what you are doing right now, without noticing. Your eyes do not glide along this line; they jump, about three times a second, and between the jumps they are nearly blind, yet the page looks steady. Each eye has a blind spot about 5 degrees wide, a hole in the picture where the optic nerve leaves the retina, and you have never seen it, because the brain fills it in. The memory of your last birthday feels like a recording, but every time you recall it, it is rebuilt from pieces, and a few details are quietly replaced. None of this is visible from the inside. It had to be discovered by experiment, and much of it was discovered within living memory.

The questions that remain open are among the largest in science. How does a feeling of red, or of pain, arise from the electrical and chemical traffic of nerve cells? How much of a person, from temperament to intelligence to the risk of depression, is inherited, and what does “inherited” even mean for a trait that changes with every experience? Why did 26 of the 40 ordinary men in a 1963 experiment keep giving what they believed were painful electric shocks to a stranger, only because a man in a grey coat told them to continue? Why do two people look at the same photograph of a dress and see different colours? Each of these questions has a research literature, a set of methods, and a handful of findings that hold up, and the units of this masterclass present them.

Psychology became a laboratory science at a definite moment. In 1879 Wilhelm Wundt (1832-1920) set aside a few rooms at the University of Leipzig for experiments on perception and reaction time, and students came from across Europe and America to learn a method in which a mental event was something you could time to the thousandth of a second. A decade later William James (1842-1910) published The Principles of Psychology, a book of 1890 that is still read for its observations on attention, habit, and the stream of thought. Since then the field has changed its mind several times about what counts as evidence, from reports of inner experience to counts of behaviour to images of the working brain, and each change left behind methods that are still in use.

This masterclass begins where the field begins, with method. Nothing in the later units can be judged without the tools of this one: how a question is turned into an experiment, how data are described with a few numbers, how large an effect is, and what a claim of “statistically significant” does and does not mean. The unit ends with the moment in 2015 when psychology tested itself by repeating 100 of its own published experiments, and with what has changed since. A reader who finishes this unit will read every later finding, in this masterclass and outside it, with a different eye.

The full unit is part of the program

Want to see a complete unit first? Unit 3, Sensation and Perception, is free to read.